Showing posts with label Article. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Article. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 30, 2011

The missing taxpayers

The missing taxpayers 
They travel abroad regularly, live in palatial homes and drive luxury vehicles. They are 2.3-million strong – they are the affluent Pakistanis who are also distinguished because they do not pay any taxes. They don’t even have a tax number, which suggests that these 2.3 million affluent Pakistanis have never paid taxes in Pakistan.

This is about to change, if one were to believe Salman Siddiqui, Chairman of the Pakistan’s Federal Bureau of Revenue (FBR). The FBR has issued notices to the 700,000 wealthiest of the 2.3 million affluent Pakistanis to pony up withheld taxes. Mr. Siddiqui did not elaborate on the penalties for those who would continue  to evade taxes.

Tax evasion in Pakistan leaves the State with no option but to borrow money from lenders, such as the IMF. Consider this: in a nation of 180 million, fewer than two million are registered tax payers. Furthermore, tax revenue accounts for roughly 10 per cent of Pakistan’s GDP, which is extremely low even for Pakistan. The average among western European states is around 30-plus per cent. In neighbouring India, tax revenue accounts for 18 per cent of the GDP, which makes me wonder whether Indians have a better sense of citizenship than Pakistanis.

In the words of the famous Canadian-born economist, John K. Galbraith, this leads to the classic case of “private opulence and public squalor” where the desire and demand for private goods is enhanced while spending on public utilities such as schools and parks decreases. In fact, Pakistan’s society and economy epitomises private opulence and public squalor where the fortunes of the rich and wealthy keep growing, while the State of Pakistan gets buried deeper in domestic and international debt.

The FBR has to squeeze hard these bloated tax-evading lemons. I would argue that even the sovereignty of Pakistan rests on the unpaid taxes of these 2.3 million affluent citizens. Consider the following numbers: if the very rich tax evaders are charged a nominal annual tax of $2,500, and the remaining 1.6 million not-so-wealthy evaders are charged $1,500 annually, this would generate an additional $4.2 billion in tax revenue.
Remember that the US is offering Pakistan annually $1.5 billion (in aid) through the Kerry Lugar Bill, in exchange for drone attacks on its own people. The $4.2 billion from the wealthiest tax-evaders could buy Pakistan its freedom from the United States.

And what of the tax penalty for avoiding taxes in the past? May I recommend a one-time penalty, $5,000 for the very rich and $2,500 for the second-tier rich, which would generate a one-time revenue of $7.5 billion. This is exactly the amount that the Kerry-Lugar Bill has promised for Pakistan over 5 years. Again the very rich, by paying their back taxes as one-time penalty, can off-set Pakistan’s dependence on American assistance.

The amounts I have suggested in taxes are not excessive by any account. It was only last month when we learnt that renowned Pakistani singer, Rahat Fateh Ali Khan was caught with undeclared $124,000 in cash at the New Delhi airport. Rahat Fateh Ali Khan reportedly has no tax history in Pakistan. Would people like him find a few thousand dollars in taxes, burdensome?

Asking the very rich in Pakistan (who make several trips abroad for which the airfare of a single trip alone is around $1,500) to dole out $2,500 (or $1,500) in taxes is certainly not excessive. If you consider the equity they hold in their palatial homes or the luxury vehicles they drive, the amount I have suggested in taxes would appear insignificant for the very rich.

I live in a middle-class neighbourhood in Toronto, Canada, where I pay over $5,500 in property tax alone. My total tax bill (income and other consumption taxes) is an order of magnitude higher than my property tax bill. In fact, in Canada income taxes are the largest single line item in a household’s budget, followed by shelter and transport costs.

Canadians pay taxes even when they disagree with how the government spends their tax dollars. Consider the current right-wing government of Prime Minister Stephen Harper that has followed a more fear-laden agenda and has shifted towards spending on building prisons and buying fighter jets from the United States. Most Canadians abhor such spending decisions because Canada has experienced a significant decline in violent crime rate over the past decade and hence, does not need new prisons. Furthermore, Canada does not face any security threats from other countries for which it may need new fighter jets. Building prisons and buying fighter jets seems a huge waste of tax-payers’ dollars. Yet, I and other Canadians do not even for a second think of withholding taxes on the pretext that our tax dollars may be wasted on futile projects.

The relationship between the State and the citizen is defined by the citizen’s willingness to pay taxes. Withholding taxes weakens the State. A weakened State has no alternative but to compromise. In Pakistan’s case, it is not the politicians alone who have pushed the State to beg from the IMF or the United States. Instead, it is the citizens of Pakistan who refuse to buy a stake in the country’s future by paying taxes, have forced the State to borrow from IMF and other lenders.

All Pakistanis, irrespective of their political or religious persuasions, hate their country’s dependence on handouts from the United States, the IMF, the World Bank and other similar institutions. The easiest and surest way to break free of this economic dependency is for Pakistanis to pay their taxes.

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Conference on doing business in Pakistan to be held on February 10

LONDON, Feb 3 (APP): A conference to identify opportunities for doing business in Pakistan is being jointly organised here on February 10 by the UK Trade and Investment and Pakistan High Commission. The event will take place at the Lancaster House where Pakistan’s Minister for Investment Saleem Mandiwala and British Minister for Trade and Investment Lord Green will be the key note speakers. High Commissioner for Pakistan to the UK Wajid Shamsul Hasan and his British counterpart in Islamabad Adam Thomson will also address the conference.


The event will highlight business opportunities in Pakistan for the UK companies. Over 100 UK companies are already operating successfully in Pakistan and the bilateral trade between the UK and Pakistan is worth over 1 billion pounds annually.


PHC spokesperson said Thursday the event aims to identify opportunities for business in Pakistan besides hearing views from the market of both government and business leaders.


“It will also help in creating understanding of the procurement process and aid funded business and infrastructure opportunities in Pakistan as well as support available to the UK companies seeking to do business in Pakistan,” the spokesperson added.

The event is significant in the context of Pakistan’s privatization programme. Other prominent speakers who will share their views from the market include Asian Development Bank’s Director General for Central and West Asia, Juan Miranda ,Chief Executive, Hubco Power Pakistan, Vince Harris and Chief Executive HSBC in Pakistan Lloyd Maddock.
A large number of British companies will also be participating in the day long event.

We have culture of corruption: Hafeez



We have culture of corruption: Hafeez

Islamabad—Federal Minister for Finance and Revenues, Dr.Abdul Hafeez Sheikh has said Pakistan needs reforms in taxation system by replacing the weak taxation machinery with efficient and vibrant tax collecting machinery for the economic prosperity of the country.

“We have a weak tax collection machinery; we have a culture of corruption; we have limited incentives; we don’t have the technology; so it is a combination of things,” he told a private TV Channel in an interview.

The Finance Minister said that the country needs reforms in the tax collecting mechanism, adding in the coming budget people would see many proposals aimed at reforms in FBR in this regard.

He said the government is very serious in reforms in FBR, because ratio of taxes to GDP of our country is just 10 per cent that is not sustainable. He added that in order to overcome the issue the government is holding political dialogue with various political parties aimed at taking every body on board and steps should be taken to enhance that tax to GDP ratio for the benefit of the country.

Dr.Hafeez Sheikh said that the main aim and objective behind the introduction of Reformed General Sales Tax (RGST) was the documentation of the national economy and bring the tax evaders into tax net. “It is often argued that we are relying on indirect taxes, but in an economy both direct and indirect taxes are levied. For levying direct taxes the government needs complete data, which can be made available from documentation of the economy,” he said.

He said there isn’t any right estimate as to how much wealth or tax able amount remained out of tax net, adding that indeed big enough amount remains out of the tax net.

He said former finance minister Shaukat Tareen had put the figure at Rs.500 billion; but even if it is Rs.300 billion or so, it is a big enough amount”, he remarked.

Federal Minister for Finance and Revenues, Dr.Abdul Hafeez Sheikh also said that the recently entire bureaucracy in the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has been reshuffled and competent officers been placed on the key posts.

However, he said due to prudent economic policies of the government the foreign exchange reserves have increased to over $ 16 billion; fiscal deficit was reduced to 5.3 from 7.6 per cent. He said new programmes were initiated for the under privileged masses adding that important and unprecedented steps like introduction of capital gain tax were levied on the most affluent class of the country.

Similarly the minimum taxable income was increased from one hundred thousand to three hundred thousand rupees per annum. “So an effort was made to reduce the burden of tax on the lower middle class people and five million people are being given targeted subsidy.”, he remarked.

The Minister said, one should know that tussle between two major parties in the country in the 90’s gave rise to the corruption in the state run bodies. He said corruption is the problem of other countries too but we should be aggressive enough in checking this menace. He said for the first time in the history of the country the Public Accounts Committee is being headed by the Leader of the Opposition in the National Assembly.

He said the biggest critic of the government is heading the biggest body to counter corruption; this is also the first time that many news channels are freely criticizing the government and highlighting the corruption; so there are emerging forces which are countering corruption. “Did we witness in the past the way Supreme Court is taking cognizance of the corrupt practices,” he questioned.

Hafeez said in any civilized society all institutions including judiciary and media go hand in hand. He said it was the decision of the cabinet to freeze the level of expenditures to the level of last year adding that it is planning to reduce the expenses of the state bodies to 30 per cent. Dr.Hafeez Sheikh said that the government has to give Rs.160 billion to the flood victims and Rs.300 billion are to be given to the provinces; so an environment of social security is getting emerged.

Saturday, January 29, 2011

Pakistan - South Asia's sick man

Pakistan - South Asia's sick man

Today, Pakistan is South Asia’s sick man. This year – the financial year ending on June 30 – if the Pakistani economy grows at all, the rate of increase will be no more than the rate of growth in population. This means that there will be no increase in average income and, for most of the population, income per head will decline. This will add another 10 million to the pool of poverty, bringing the total to over 70 million. In the immediate future, the national output is likely to increase at a rate less than one-half of that expected for Bangladesh and one-third of that projected for India.

I pointed this out to Pakistan’s President Asif Ali Zardari in a recent meeting. He responded by saying that by comparing the performances of India, Bangladesh and Pakistan I was comparing apples and oranges. India had had a democratic system of government for more than 60 years and Bangladesh had been under democratic rule for a longer period than Pakistan. He said he had inherited a damaged economy and a dysfunctional political system from a military dictator. His government’s first priority was to provide the country with a political system that was fully representative of the wishes of the citizenry.

My purpose for bringing to the attention of the Pakistani president the divergent tracks being followed by the major economies of mainland South Asia was to suggest that there were public policy lessons to be learnt from the development experiences of India and Bangladesh. However, upon reflection I thought that the president was raising a valid point: the importance of a democratic system for sustained economic development. One thing that stood out in India’s case – and to some extent also in the case of Bangladesh – was the continuity in the making of economic policy. In a democratic system policy makers would not be allowed to make sudden changes in the direction of policy unless it was warranted. The Indian electorate punished Indira Gandhi when she put the country under an emergency. It rewarded the Congress party when it gave up, during a period of deep financial crisis, the discredited “license raj” in favour of a more open economy. In Pakistan, however, the roller coaster political ride – alternating between civilian and military rules – had also resulted in wide swings in the economic priorities pursued by those in power.

Pakistan will have the single largest Muslim population by 2030

Doomed generation?

ACCORDING to a study released on Thursday by the Washington-based Pew Research Centre, the world`s Muslim population — currently at 1.6 billion — is projected to reach 2.2 billion by 2030. The growth of the Muslim population will slow down over the next two decades, from an average annual rate of 2.2 per cent in 1990-2010 to 1.5 per cent in 2010-2030. Nevertheless, Muslims` pace of population increase will be about twice the rate of that of non-Muslims. By 2030 Muslims will constitute 26.4 per cent of the world`s population, which is expected to have swelled by then to 8.3 billion.

This information must be framed in the context of the global population`s competition over resources, both natural and man-made, and over opportunities for economic and other sorts of benefits. While the sum total of the essentials of human life is shrinking, the number of people who must share them is increasing. Worst-affected are the poorer countries and their people. Fierce competition over access to education and health services as well as job opportunities is leading to growing numbers of people from under-deve- loped countries to seek immigration to the deve- loped nations. This, no less than other factors, is causing a number of developed countries to tighten immigration laws. The findings of the Pew study must be taken as a signal for a more equitable division of the world`s resources. Some of the most under-developed countries in the world are Muslim countries. Their governments must make a serious push to improve welfare indexes across the board, and the developed world must help in doing this.

The problem is mirrored in the situation Pakistan faces. The Pew research indicates that by 2030 Pakistan will have surpassed Indonesia as the country with the single largest Muslim population. More worryingly, during the next two decades this country`s population is expected to grow from the current 178 million to 256 million — and this despite the fact that population planning programmes have been successful in bringing birth rates in the country down somewhat. Does Pakistan have a plan to ensure a steady growth of resources and infrastructure to match the needs of a burgeoning population? Hardly. The needs of even today`s citizenry are far from being met. It is estimated that one child in four is acutely malnourished, and the problems of access to education, health services and jobs, if available, are well-known. Projected into the future, the situation appears frightening. There is a need for a two-pronged effort if the generations to come are to be saved. On the one hand, the state must start some serious planning. On the other, the birth rate must be brought down further.

Friday, January 28, 2011

Control price hike or face Tunisia-like situation

 
ISLAMABAD: The opposition in the National Assembly (NA) on Thursday warned the government to control the rising prices of items of daily use or get ready to face a “Tunisia” like revolution that will sweep everything with it.

As the debate on skyrocketing prices of essential items of daily use commenced, interestingly no member of the economic team of the government was present in the house.

PML-N legislator Rana Tanveer-ul-Hasan, who kicked off the debate, demanded rightsizing of the National Assembly itself, arguing that after the number of MNAs was increased to 342, expenditure had increased tremendously. However, he did not elaborate what kind of right sizing in the NA was needed.

He warned that if efforts to control the prices were not made or were made half-heartedly, the situation could go out of control. He demanded abolition of monopolies and letting atmosphere of fair competition prevail. “This could be an effective step to control the prices,” he said.

Rana Tanveer suggested that the government should take visible checks to reduce the prices and stop printing currency notes to meet the government expenses. Raja Asad Khan of the PML-N came down hard on the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP), saying that instead of spending Rs70 billion on such a project to get cheap publicity, the government should construct a dam in the name of Benazir Bhutto to provide cheap electricity to the people.

He was of the view that economic policies of the government should be for the benefit of the masses. No loans should be taken from foreign donors. He warned that if the prices were not controlled, the situation could take the shape of a revolution in which case, the rulers will not be able to escape the fury of the people.

Fauzia Wahab did not see any gloomy picture of the economy, saying that the economic indicators prove that the economy is moving in the right direction. She said that agriculture sector showed a growth of Rs300 billion during a year while textile exports fetched $1.5 billion on monthly basis and $10 billion were received through remittances.

She held terrorism responsible for all the economic ills of Pakistan and said that till terrorism was brought under control, stability in economy would remain a far cry. She said terrorists were getting bails from the judiciary and the conviction rate in Pakistan was 20 percent, which is very low as compared with other parts of the world where conviction rate is 80 percent.

However, Raza Hayat Hiraj of PML-Q did not agree with Fauzia Wahab’s thinking and asked if the economic situation was not that bad, then why the government was approaching the opposition for joint efforts for the stabilization of economy. “If the economic picture is rosy, then why did the government take a loan of $13 billion from the IMF?” he questioned.

He suggested that all the party heads should sit down to find out the causes of the price hike to formulate a joint economic strategy. Chief Whip of PML-N Sheikh Aftab stressed the need for good governance and questioned as to why reputed professionals were not being inducted to run huge public sector enterprises to make them profitable.

Obviously referring to the 10-point agenda of the PML-N, Sheikh Aftab said that it was for the first time that instead of embarrassing the government by leg pulling, the opposition was facilitating it to improve its governance.

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

An imminent food price increase


An imminent food price increase

IN this space last week I wrote about the likelihood of Pakistan’s already battered economy receiving another shock sometime soon. In 2011 the economy is likely to be hurt by an imminent and significant rise in the prices of commodities.

Last week, I wrote about the recent trends in the movement of two groups of commodities: energy producing items and metals. Today I will turn to the likely impact of a number of global developments on the prices of agricultural commodities several of which are important in Pakistan’s import basket.
There is a mounting anxiety in international circles that we are about to witness an extraordinary increase in the prices of several agricultural commodities that enter the food chain.

While the economy was hammered by a number of domestic developments in the last couple of years – some of them brought on by nature such as the flood last summer of biblical proportions and some by poor public policies – further shocks are likely to be delivered by a series of developments in the international market place over which policymakers have no control.

In these difficult times Pakistan cannot afford to alienate its foreign friends. The policymakers’ poor performance in the area of domestic resource mobilisation means that its relations with the International Monetary Fund and much of the Western world will remain strained. Pakistan’s leaders will have to demonstrate that they can gather the political will needed to introduce long postponed structural reforms in particular of the tax system. They will need to do this before the donors are prepared to loosen their purse strings and come to the country’s help one more time. Help will be needed if the prices of the imported commodities increase and begin to eat into the accumulated reserves.

Much of IMF $11.3 billion standby credit has arrived and is responsible for taking the foreign exchange reserves to a comfortable level. But the Fund has stopped further disbursements since Pakistan has not been able to meet one of the more important conditions: improving the tax system to generate more resources from within the economy. With the Fund stepping aside, Pakistan has very limited options available to meet the pressure on external accounts that will result from a rise in commodity prices.

As is usually the case with commodities, price rises are the result of a number of factors: natural disasters and changes in weather conditions, changes in the structure of demand in large countries, actions by the governments across the globe, and speculation in the forward markets. All these are in play at this time.
Russia, a major producer of wheat had one of the hottest and rainiest summers in 2010. That affected wheat output. Australia has faced serious floods in their summer (our winter) as did Pakistan. Both countries are important producers of several commodities. Argentina had a long dry spell that has affected its grain output.
Financial speculators are adding fuel to the fire that is burning in the commodities markets. Money flows have been large in recent months. Barclays Capital estimates $60 billion was injected into commodities in 2010 contributing to the increase in these prices.

Figures from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the US regulator, reveals very bullish bets among many mangers such as hedge funds. Concerns about speculation in the markets has prompted the United States Congress to begin to worry about the impact on the level of prices that may follow heavy trading by speculators not connected with the fundamentals of the market – supply and demand changes. Some US Senators have warned of a “speculative bubble that threatens to drive up gas and food prices even further.” They have threatened to take legislative action if the speculators continue to affect market stability.

Prices of agricultural commodities jumped recently after the United States government surprised the forward markets with the announcement that its stocks of key crops were running very low. The US Department of Agriculture said in a statement that the ratio of stocks-to-demand will fall this year to their lowest level since the mid-1970s. That was the last time the world went through a food scarcity scare. The international community at that time reacted quickly. A World Food Conference was convened in Rome which led to the creation of the International Fund for Agricultural Development, IFAD. This new UN agency was tasked with the responsibility for increasing investment in agriculture in the developing world.

For the moment no international action is contemplated as was the case in 1974. The result is that most governments are taking steps on their own. Some of these are likely to aggravate the situation as happened with the decision by Moscow to ban most agricultural exports. Moscow has said that the restrictions it placed on the export of many food products will remain in place until the end of 2011. South Korea and the Philippines have suspended some of their import duties on food items such as fish and powdered milk.
In December, Sri Lanka released rice stocks and re-imposed a price ceiling that had been removed in October 2010. The Indian government is very nervous about the price of onions that soared 80 per cent in just one week. It has allowed the import of onions from wherever it is available.

According to the Financial Times, “still in its infancy, 2011 is conjuring up memories of the start of 2008. Soaring crop prices have stoked fears of a food crisis and oil markets are bubbling…Prices of corn, soyabeans and wheat in January returned to heights that only two years ago sparked riots in more than 30 countries from Haiti to Bangladesh”.

For obvious reasons the poor are hurt more by a rise in the price of food. For them food constitutes a larger proportion of the budget than for other income groups. According to the World Bank, 65 million were thrown into poverty in 2008 and 2009 as a result of food price increases.

For the moment the prices of the crops that are important items of import by Pakistan have risen while those the country exports have stayed steady. The price of rice, by far the most important agricultural export, is likely to remain steady compared to some other food crops that are imported.
The group that matters the most for Pakistan are the oil bearing crops. The news about the stock situation in the United States resulted in a sharp increase in the price of corn and soya bean. They increased to their highest levels in 30 months. Both crops are important in this group of commodities.

There is a long history of food price increases causing political problems for governments in power which is one reason why policymakers react quickly – sometimes irrationally – to food inflation. Ayub Khan was brought down in the spring of 1969 by public agitation following the rise in the price of sugar, an
important item of consumption for the poor.

Rising food prices may have been an ingredient in the political movement that drove Tunisia’s president, Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali, from office and out of the country. One of the measures Ben Ali used a few days before throwing in his hat was to cut prices for sugar, cooking oil and other commodities. There are lessons in these experiences for Pakistan.

In a weakened and weakening political system a commodity price shock may be hard to absorb since it affects the poor and the lower middle classes more than the classes represented in the political establishment. The government needs to prepare itself and do it soon to deal with this expected shock to the troubled economy.

Saturday, January 15, 2011

PEW expresses concern on PPP-led government excessive borrowing

PEW expresses concern on PPP-led government excessive borrowing

ISLAMABAD : The Pakistan Economy Watch (PEW) Thursday expressed concern on the PPP-led federal government’s excessive budgetary borrowing, as on the average it taking Rs68 billion (or US$795 million) a month from the banking system to fill its income-expenditure gap while ignoring its ’negative fallouts’ in shape of rising inflation that hitting hard the poor the most.

Only from the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP), the federal government is borrowing about 28 billion a month.
The President of PEW, Dr. Murtaza Mughal said, "The excessive borrowing from the central bank is diluting the effects of the SBP tight monetary policy and causing ’inflation’ to go up further". He added it also signaling towards the slower pace of the economy.
 
Currently, the state bank of Pakistan discount rate is highest in the region at 14 per cent. The bank tight its monetary policy to rein in the skyrocketing inflation, but on the other hand the government borrowing from SBP is ’nullifying’ possible positive effects of the bank policy.
 
Despite tight monetary policy, inflation is in double digit and above expectation. During 2010 CPI inflation rose to 15.68 per cent against 10.52 per cent in corresponding month of the last year and first half (July-December 2010-11), average inflation stood at 14.65 per cent.
 
He said as the public spending helps in developing right infrastructure for encouraging private investment; however, as the government spending is huge and not accompanying by increase in government revenue and proportionate increase in GDP, so it created public debt and inflation to go up. The higher government spending is also putting upward pressure on the interest rates and discouraging private investors borrow and invest in the economy and flourish their businesses.
 
He said, "the government should control its lavish spending and rein in the leakages from its state-run enterprises, as ultimately, it is the poor masses that finance it through their hard-earn ’tax money’ and in shape of higher inflation"
Elaborating, Dr. Mughal said, as these issues are causing budget deficit to widen, and for its financing it borrow from the banks, the bank print the money and there become a situation when "too much money chases too few goods" and the inflation shoots up.
 
While referring to the latest data of the State Bank, he said, "The central government during last six- month (from July to end December, 2010) has borrowed huge Rs408 billion from the banking system, which makes per month average borrowing to Rs68 billion". He added that out of this amount, about Rs168 billion were been borrowed from the state bank, while Rs240 billion from scheduled banks.
 
Dr. Mughal also said, the federal government’s this year borrowing was three-and-a-half-time more than what it borrowed Rs116 billion during same period of the last year. While, the provincial governments instead of borrowing have retired 76 billion debt of the State Bank of Pakistan and borrowed Rs6.15 billion from scheduled banks during the period.
 
He proposed the government to do legislation as soon as possible on "SBP Act" which envisages restrictions on the government borrowing from the central bank and which is still pending with the Senate.
The National Assembly has already approved it. However, some officials of the ministry of finance say that the government was dillydallying in getting through the Act from the Upper House as to avoid restrictions in the existing economic situation where revenue shortfall and expenditure overrun were forcing the government to pursue the SBP for providing money for budgetary support without any limit.

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Pakistan Facing a "Convergence of Risks"

Pakistan Facing a "Convergence of Risks"

Capital raising efforts to aid Pakistan's economic development could be curtailed in the wake of the latest political crisis.


The latest political crisis in Pakistan could hurt the country’s chances of securing IMF loans, resulting in a tough capital raising climate over the next few years, according to Standard Chartered Bank's country economist in Pakistan.

“While the PPP-led government is likely to survive the latest political crisis, it no longer has sufficient support in parliament to pass the tax reforms committed to under the IMF stand-by arrangement,” said Sayem Ali, Standard Chartered Bank’s country economist in Pakistan, in an interview with Suite 101.

Over the course of last week tensions between the ruling government and other parties have intensified after the assassination of Salman Taseer, a key aide of current President Asif Ali Zardari of the PPP. Taseer was governor of Punjab, Pakistan’s largest and most populous province.

Meanwhile, the country is still recovering from devastating floods in September 2010 that left 20 million people displaced and over 6 million people in immediate need of aid. The disaster pushed Pakistan’s economic agenda back, making it more difficult to kick-start growth and create employment opportunities.
Ali says there is an entirely different story on the ground in Pakistan, one about the opportunity for businesses in the country.

Last month, the London Stock Exchange (LSE) hosted its first Pakistan Privatisation and Capital Markets Forum, highlighting the investment opportunities available in Pakistani public and private sector companies to London-based investors.
 
Ibukun Adebayo, Head of Business Development in South Asia for the LSE said that the exchange, as the world’s most international equity market, was uniquely placed to facilitate investor meetings for some of Pakistan’s leading companies and a chance for London-based investors to see the potential for high growth and returns in Pakistan.
€Attending companies included Pakistan Petroleum, Pakistan Steel, United Bank and others.

Pakistan's government pushes through reforms but loses political capital

If the government cannot push unpopular tax reforms through, the IMF may end the programme prematurely, not releasing a $3.4 billion tranche of the $11.3 billion stand-by arrangement loan. There has been no distribution of funds from the IMF since May 2010.
Ali says the government deserves credit for some of the fiscal reforms passed in the last three years. A domestic power tax was increased by close to 95 percent and petroleum product subsidies were terminated under conditions of the IMF loan agreed to in 2008. As well, exchange rate reforms were passed to stabilise Pakistan’s currency.
“We have seen the government running out of time, the IMF has given until September this year to comply with remaining performance targets, but time is passing for them to push through some difficult reforms,” said Ali.
Economic reforms over the last three years have caused inflation to sky-rocket to 66 percent which in turn has created political instability. Anger over a fuel price hike forced the ruling government in retreat last week and Pakistan’s Prime Minister, Yusuf Raza Gilani, reversed the rise to save a shaky government, bringing allies back into the fold.
Reversal of the fuel hike further increased tensions with the US and various media reports state that Secretary of State Hillary Clinton called the move a “mistake”. US Vice President Joe Biden is expected to visit Pakistan this week.

Funding for Pakistan missing in action

Promised funds from other agencies have been slow in arriving, says Ali, adding that the government of Pakistan says they are owed $2.5 billion dollars under the coalition support fund. This funding was for military services provided by the Pakistani army that were rendered in 2010.
Economic aid in the form of the Kerry-Lugar bill included a pledge of $1.5 billion annual economic assistance, but in the last year since legislation was passed by the US congress, only $500 million has been dispersed, of which $200 million was released just last week and through the UN flood aid appeal.
“I am not really sure what the issues are, but it’s been slow and its made things more complicated for the government for sure,” said Sayem Ali.

He forecasts the slowdown in currency inflows to test the strength of the rupee as major creditors suspend disbursements due to the deteriorating fiscal position, but points to inflation as the immediate
risk.

Pakistanis are tax evaders

Study says majority of high earners do not pay tax
Majority of Pakistanis who never paid a single penny as taxes throughout their life are highly qualified, live in the most expensive locations like the DHAs in Karachi and Lahore, have their accounts in foreign banks and make frequent travelling abroad, disclosed a study.
 
The research carried out by the National Database and Registration Authority (Nadra) has unfolded another most alarming fact that the segment of population under question does not possess the National Tax Numbers (NTNs) in the first place. And individuals falling in this category are more than half-a-million, according to a conservative estimate.
 
If each one of them is taxed at the rate of Rs75,000 annually, that is bare minimum as compared to their income, it will fetch revenue to the tune of Rs40 billion, a target that the government instead wants to achieve through the imposition of Reformed General Sales Tax (RGST).
 
This non-tax paying elitekeeps their wealth in foreign accounts. Of them, more than 33 per cent individuals have two or more accounts in foreign banks like American Express Bank, Bank of Tokyo, HSBC, Barclays, Standard Chartered, RBS, Citi Bank and others. There are a sizeable number of females also marked in this
category and 75 per cent of them have accounts in foreign banks.
 
The study further notes that majority of the non-taxpayers in this category are the young entrepreneurs of rich background as being the scions of wealthy parents, falling in the age bracket of 25 to 45 years. Pakistan’s adult population is 86 million and only 2.5 million are in the tax net with its major portion, 1.8 million, constituted by the salaried class. Pakistan’s tax-to-GDP ratio is 9.6 per cent, the lowest in the world where there are only 1.2 million active taxpayers and the remaining either have their tax deducted from salaries or evade taxes.
 
Among the 10 largest cities, Karachi hosts the highest number of wealthy people who are not registered with the tax authorities, thus, they never paid tax, followed in order by Lahore, Rawalpindi, Islamabad, Faisalabad, Peshawar, Hyderabad, Multan, Quetta and Gujranwala.
Nadra Chairman Ali Arshad Hakeem was not available for comments. However, well placed Nadra officials verified the contents of this study that, they said, was aimed at helping the Federal Board of Revenue to bring more people into the tax net.
 
Previously, Nadra had spotted the tax evaders providing a list of E-7 residents whose majority does not pay taxes. These non-taxpayers were found out through Nadra’s data mines by examining the areas such folks reside, their accounts in foreign banks, nature of business/profession, travelling patterns and relations abroad. Through this exercise, Nadra found out 565,953 such individuals who never paid income tax. Of them, 79 per cent were male and 21 per cent female.
 
The study found out that Karachi has the largest number of such non-taxpayers (154,479) living in DHA, Clifton and at other posh locations. Lahore followed by 77,568 such non-taxpayers residing in DHA and other expensive places. Rawalpindi has been ranked third with 33,381 such individuals, followed by Islamabad (18,233), Faisalabad (16,118), Peshawar (13,698), Hyderabad (13,622), Multan (12,696), Quetta (8,613), and Gujranwala (8,610).

Majority of these non-taxpayers are graduates (244,396), followed by post-graduates (192,953) and then below matriculation (37,047). Regarding the age brackets, the majority of non-tax paying individuals range between 35-45 years (220,932) followed by 25-35 years (185,749), 45-55 years (91,201), 55-65 years (44,641) and 18-25 (23,430).

Saturday, January 8, 2011

Domestic debt, defence spending make 2011 a difficult year


KARACHI: The year 2011 will be another difficult year for the country as there are a host of structural issues facing Pakistan, including one of the lowest tax collection, highest domestic debt servicing and one of the highest defence spending in the world.
“If a serious and concentrated effort is made to start addressing these issues, the investors will take it as a positive signal and start investing in Pakistan again,” said Dr Amjad Waheed, Chief Executive Officer, NBP Fullerton Asset Management (NAFA).

In 2011, government borrowing is expected to remain excessive, thus, inflation and interest rates are expected to rise further.

He said that some segments of the economy remained outside the tax ambit such as agriculture, services and real estate, thus, tax collection was under 10 percent of the GDP, one of the lowest in the world.

Domestic debt servicing was eating up around 44 percent of the government tax revenues, while defence spending was around 33 percent of the government tax revenues, which was among the highest in the world.
About structural issues, he said that the development spending, including education, healthcare, population planning, flood protection and infrastructure, etc, was substantially lower relative to other emerging markets.

“Government-owned organisations are incurring losses of around Rs300 billion per annum and excessive government borrowing during the last three years has crowded out the private sector, which is the more efficient sector.”

Private sector borrowing has come down from Rs366 billion during FY2007 to Rs71 billion during FY 2011 (July-December, 2010), whereas government borrowing during the same time has risen from Rs164 billion to Rs450 billion and no focused effort has been made by successive governments to develop alternative sources of energy, such as coal, hydel, wind, etc.

In 2010, foreign portfolio investment in the Pakistani stock market stood at around $500 million. In the same year, around $30 billion has been invested by foreign investors in the Indian stock market.

India’s economy is 10 times larger than that of Pakistan. On this basis, if $30 billion is invested in the Indian stock market, than around $3 billion should have been invested in the Pakistani stock market instead of $500 million.

“Concrete progress to redress the abovementioned structural issues can help increase foreign investment in Pakistan several fold, improving job creation and government tax collection

US' worst fears realised as Pak Govt stalls economic reforms to stay in power

US' worst fears realised as Pak Govt stalls economic reforms to stay in power 
"The extension will provide time to the Pakistani authorities to complete the reform of the General Sales Tax, implement measures to correct the course of fiscal policy, and amend the legislative framework for the financial sector," the IMF said through its press office on Friday.

The Pakistani government appears to have calculated that the country is too strategically important for the US and the IMF, and that even though Pakistan has balked on reforms, the international community would come through with support, the report said.

"Nobody realizes that the government of President Zardari is essentially performing a juggling act," said a senior Pakistani government official, referring to President Asif Ali Zardari. (ANI)

The country has received 7.6 billion dollars so far, but the fund has extended the time for its next payment and has not given Pakistan any further instalments since May.

The bargain underscored an increasingly urgent problem for both Pakistan and its international backers, especially the United States, which has pushed the government to improve its tax collection and make hard economic choices to ensure the nation's solvency, the New York Times reported.
This week's turmoil indicated that if the coalition government wants to survive, that path might be impossible, it added.

The Obama administration did not publicly criticise Pakistani officials for the deal on Friday, apparently deciding that a worse outcome would have been a collapse of the government when the US was depending on it for help in fighting the war in Afghanistan, said the report.

For the time being, then, Pakistan may remain dependent on international assistance, including billions of dollars in military and civilian aid from the US, even as fewer than two per cent of Pakistanis pay income tax, with many wealthy members of government among those who pay nothing, it added.

"The message international donors have received is that if the government cannot absorb the pressure on petrol prices, then how can it take up major economic reforms?" Ashfaque Hasan Khan, dean of the business school at the National University of Sciences and Technology in Islamabad, told the local news media.

The increase in fuel prices was deeply unpopular, hitting the poor hardest, and fraught with political risks of its own.

"All the political parties saw this as an opportunity to show they are on the side of the people," said Marvin Weinbaum, a scholar in residence at the Middle East Institute in Washington and a former State Department analyst on Pakistan.

But the deal is sure to ruffle the International Monetary Fund, which has promised Pakistan more than 11 billion dollars in loans to tide the government over, said the report.

Monday, January 3, 2011

Circular debt: Why the free market must replace stopgap measures

Circular debt: Why the free market must replace stopgap measures

 It is an open secret that the root of the energy crisis in the country lies in underutilisation of installed power generation capacity at oil-based power plants.

Power producers have stopped short of running on full capacity due to burgeoning default in payments by consumers. This default has fed itself as the main supply chain of furnace oil – Pakistan State Oil (PSO) – has choked, bringing it on the verge of default on account of impending payments for imported furnace oil, as well as oil purchased from other refineries.

This vicious cycle is more popularly known as ‘circular debt’, appropriately named because of its self-feeding nature.
Pakistan depends on imported oil to meet one-third of its energy demands. These imports are made by the refineries, Pak Arab Refinery Limited (Parco) for example, in the form of crude oil or by PSO in the form of furnace oil.

PSO, after purchasing from refineries or international suppliers, sells the oil to power producers, who then eventually sell electricity to distribution companies such as Karachi Electric Supply Company (KESC) or Pakistan Electric Power Company (Pepco). We end up buying electricity from these distribution companies.
Our payments are channelled backwards the same way: from distribution companies to producers to oil suppliers. Circular debt is created when this cycle is broken at any stage. Usually, this happens when some of us do not pay our share of electricity consumed.

Here ‘we’ includes residential and non-residential consumers, the latter being further divided into government bodies and commercial bodies. The KESC, for instance, has taken refuge for defaults by citing non-payments by the Sindh government.

It’s not that simple
Indeed this scenario has been simplified for the sake of understanding. As they say, there is a neat and simple solution for every problem. This is incorrect, at least in this case.
Along these lines, our government and policymakers have resorted to stopgap measures – swap the circular debt with new bonds, federal government guarantees or loans. This solution may be simple, but is hardly permanent. It has merely created a wedge between present and future by ducking in the face of tough choices.

This is the equivalent of saying to highly leveraged companies: don’t worry if KESC, a provincial government or state-owned enterprise does not pay its bills, we will ‘create’ more money and pay on their behalf. We cannot print money (international donors such as the International Monetary Fund do not allow that), but we sure can borrow from the banks.

As simple as it may sound, unfortunately this is how government has been tackling the problem of swelling circular debt.

At the beginning of the current fiscal year, circular debt stood at around Rs180 billion – roughly one per cent of the gross domestic product (GDP). Leading defaulters include the KESC and provincial governments of Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa and Sindh.

The list of accused should also include the now defunct Pepco, which failed to close in the revenue-expenditure gap, despite a hefty 100 per cent rise in the electricity tariffs in less than two years.
Neither can PSO be given a clean bill as it is the only company that provides oil on credit. No privately owned company can dare to afford such facilities to risky customers. A privately owned company does not write request letters to the ministry of finance or the prime minister pleading government intervention. When faced with ‘bad’ customers, it resorts to the courts or restructures and cancels the contracts.

The solution
Our analysts, just like government, have found an easy solution to the problem in the form of calls for honest leadership. The fault lies not with any leader, it is in our statist approach and the assumption that ‘goodwill’ can deliver via governments.

We should not just be concerned with honest leaders, we should not let the system be held hostage to human weaknesses. A system entrenched with rent-seeking is a sure call for more corruption and inefficiencies.
In comparison, a system embedded with competition, rule of law and economic freedom is more likely to deliver. This is where the heart of the matter lies.

If you observe the circular debt cycle closely, you will immediately notice it is all state versus state. It’s state-owned PSO versus state regulator Pepco. It’s KESC (even after so-called privatisation) versus the government of Sindh. It’s another distributor (even after de-bundling) versus Pakistan International Airlines or Pakistan Steel Mills.

This is what happens when you bring the government to ‘correct’ the markets. When a private business fails, it closes down. When a government business fails, it is apparently given more funds. The government managers protect each other at the cost of taxpayers.

They unilaterally raise the tariffs to cover inefficiencies and corruption and routinely take new loans to pay back old ones. This is not politics – it is dirigisme. We need to dig deep and purge our transactions from the statist approach. For that we need the free market at full swing – with all its brutality, imperfections and wonders.

Sunday, January 2, 2011

If RGST not implemented, wealth tax not restored

If RGST not implemented, wealth tax not restored

ISLAMABAD: A leading economist Dr Hafiz Pasha while portraying a horrifying picture of the economy expressed fear that if the government fails to implement the Reformed General Sales Tax (RGST) and does not restore wealth tax and enforce agriculture income tax in the provinces then the country would be in the grip of hyper inflation in a situation where the State Bank of Pakistan would be required to print new notes worth Rs 1 trillion at least.

The country is going to witness an unprecedented budget deficit to the tune of over Rs 1.2 trillion during the ongoing fiscal year and to meet this the government would be required to print Rs 1 trillion currency notes as against Rs 600 billion notes that were printed in 2008 to meet the budget deficit.
Hinting unstoppable inflation in the coming days, former Economic Advisory Council member Dr Hafiz Pasha portrayed a horrifying picture of the economy before the evening session of the 26th annual general meeting of Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE) in a scenario where deficit would be out of control resulting in printing of notes to the tune of around Rs 1 trillion.
 
He said that the economic managers have failed to prepare the impact of revenue generation, inflationary impact of RGST and also failed in taking on board all the stakeholders over the issue.
He informed that the country is going to face historic inflation in case the government is unable to take taxation measures to generate additional revenue. People are talking about the inflationary impact of RGST, but they are unaware that a time will come when the government has to print notes worth Rs 1 trillion. The inflation caused by the printing of new notes would be so high that people would forget about the inflationary impact of the RGST.
 
Dr Pasha threatened that the deficit is rising day by day and delay in the introduction of new taxation measures would result in extraordinary high inflation. The country would be in a grip of hyperinflation, which would be unstoppable. The inflationary impact due to printing of new notes would be much higher than the RGST.
 
Talking about the inflation, he hinted that inflation would further increase in coming days unless the government takes timely steps to control the situation.
Under the current circumstances, the provinces have to enforce the agricultural income tax and the government should restore the wealth tax. The provinces should have taken appropriate steps a year ago as nobody was stopping the federal government from taking measures to generate revenue.
 
He said that the government must show sense of responsibility for avoiding situation of printing notes in the coming days. It is unfortunate that the people have not been educated about the actual impact of the RGST.
He said, “I am very much worried about the constant delay in the implementation of the RGST. It is unfortunate that first the government talked about the RGST’s implementation in October, which was delayed to December. Now there is a political turmoil in January 2010. Even at technical level there is still no unanimity or consensus on all issues of the RGST.
 
Referring to a report on the inflationary impact of Dr Hafiz Pasha said that the Federal Board of revenue had asked the PIDE to compile a report on the inflationary impact of RGST, but so far the report has not been completed. There is a lack of clarity on the issue of RGST and we have not done a good job for taking this reform forward.
 
In the morning session, Dr Pasha said that we cannot give a specific date to the International Monetary Fund (IMF) for the implementation of RGST keeping in view the current situation. India has been struggling for the last 15 years to properly enforce the value-added tax (VAT), but they are unable to do so. Contrary to this, in Pakistan the sales tax reforms have just been started since the last one-year. The IMF should have to be patient as we cannot give a specific date for the implementation of RGST. We have to respect our parliament and it is not possible to give a precise date for the introduction of RGST.
 
He added that the Sales Tax Act of 1990 has all features of VAT. The concept of sales tax domestic zero-rating was made part of the RGST, which has not been done anywhere in the world.

The international VAT expert Ehtisham Ahmad said that RGST is not a new tax. It has never been considered as a new tax. The problems in the GST of 1990 would now be fixed through RGST. The performance of the existing sales tax has been continuously declining having an impact on the tax-to-gross domestic product (GDP) ratio. He said that during Musharraf tenure measures were taken at the import stage to improve the trade position of the country, which had impacted the tax-to-GDP ratio. It was a deliberate attempt to improve the trade position of the country.

Wednesday, December 29, 2010

Tied to the Donors

Tied to the Donors

Finance Minister Hafeez Shaikh is faced with a “mission impossible.” He has the arduous task of having to convince the people of Pakistan about TINA, “There Is No Alternative” to the RGST (Reformed General Sales Tax). Having tried his hand at it twice, albeit only partially successfully – when he argued that the RGST was needed to repay the IMF (International Monetary Fund) loans, and that Pakistan would not be able to pay the salaries of government employees if IMF tranches were not disbursed – the finance minister and his colleagues have recently peddled a host of other arguments. They argue that the RGST is not a new tax and that it is needed to document the economy. They say it would also enhance the country’s tax-to-GDP ratio. However, the long and short of the RGST is that its levy would secure the remaining $3.4 billion out of $11.3 standby loans and that, in turn, would help us negotiate another loan. Failure to get the IMF nod would not only mean the loss of the amount due from the IMF, it would also jeopardise disbursement of loans from international financial institutions.

Since 1988, Pakistan has concluded four packages with the IMF. A bird’s-eye view of these packages would help understand the economic quagmire in which Pakistan is currently bogged down (see “Package Deal”).
After 20 years of IMF-World Bank dictated programmes, Pakistan’s dependence on foreign aid has grown to such an extent that today it is being kept afloat by donors and international financial institutions. Shaikh has made it known that when the current package with IMF lapses in December 2010, extendable to March 2011, the government would like to negotiate another package with the IMF. This would mean betrothing Pakistan to an IMF package for a quarter of a century.

Anger against the IMF runs high in Pakistan. Photo: AFP

Del302367Ever since its birth in 1947, prophets of doom have made predictions about the viability of Pakistan, and their voices became louder after the separation of East Pakistan in 1971. During the 1990s, such predictions were fuelled when Pakistan was ranked the second most corrupt country in the world. Termination of US aid in August 1990, revealed that Pakistan was being kept afloat by outside help.
During recent weeks, there has been a plethora of reports such as “Pakistan economy on the verge of collapse,”  “What went wrong?” “Is the country headed for a point of no return?” and “The meltdown has begun.” Statistics and articles are increasingly documenting the number of people falling below the poverty line, poor governance, rising incidence of corruption, breakdown of utilities, law and order and regional disparities. Pakistan’s biggest federating unit in the south is in revolt, the state is at war with its own people in the north, its green passport holders are treated as untouchables and non-resident Pakistanis returning from a visit abroad are treated as suspected terrorists. Two-digit galloping inflation, nepotism, black marketing and breakdown of law and order is the order of the day. One could go on listing the ailments from which Pakistan’s economy is suffering, but the most distinct of them on the economic front are the national debt, the circular debt and power shortages.
Pakistan’s domestic and external debt is the cumulative result of living beyond our means for 60 years. In the year 2010, the federal government is borrowing at a rate of Rs 1.5 billion every day. In 2001, when a former World Bank vice-president Dr Pervez Hassan submitted a Debt Retirement Strategy, former finance minister Sartaj Aziz had called it “a borrow-more-to-retire” debt strategy. Commenting on the strategy, then World Bank resident representative John Wall had aptly said: “Pakistan is in a hole and still digging.” The debt quagmire is becoming inextricable.
In 2006, in my book, Pakistan Sovereignty Lost – a history of how Pakistan was bogged down in the debt trap – I wrote that Shaukat Aziz would go down in Pakistan’s history as the prime minister under whom external debt snowballed, while the government trumpeted claims of reducing the size of the external debt. That prediction is coming true in 2010 as reflected by Finance Minister Hafeez Shaikh’s statements.
The finance minister’s claims that without the RGST Pakistan would not be able to repay IMF loans, calls for soul-searching rather than going ahead with the stopgap arrangements that have been tried time and again in the last 20 years. The million-dollar question posed to the finance minister and his office should be, what has happened to more than 100 billion dollars in aid and almost an equal amount in grants, if Pakistan cannot repay even $5 billion per annum? It also speaks volumes about the utility of foreign aid.
Pakistan has repaid at least $55 billion, including the principal amount and interest to-date, and has an outstanding external debt of $55 billion. But in actual fact the total external debt is much larger than the official figures.  It was brought down artificially through a trick by Shaukat Aziz’s government when former Economic Advisor Dr Ashfaq Hassan innovated a new term called “contingency liabilities.” A whole new chapter of contingency liabilities was added to the Economic Survey in 2001.
Cost_Living_Index12-10Contingency liabilities mainly relate to sovereign guarantees that Pakistan has extended to 25 independent power producers producing 7,600 MW of electricity and created a major fiscal anomaly whereby contingency liabilities do not form part of the national debt, but are being paid for by the government. The fact that the figures of total debt and debt repayments might be under-invoiced was conceded by the Economic Survey for 2009-10, when it observed that “reported debt levels of a sovereign may be understated owing to the non-inclusion of guarantees, explicit or implicit, which may materialise in future.” The fiscal mess created by these liabilities could be gauged from the mere fact that nearly one trillion rupees have been paid in the last seven years.
It is intriguing that neither any government functionary nor international financial institutions view snowballing payments to IPPs (Independent Power Projects) as a concern, because in this sector interests of the profit-making foreigners, corrupt politicians and bureaucracy concur. The million-dollar question remains – why have WAPDA or government sectors not set up a single project? The PPP manifesto of 2002 states that IMF-World Bank conditionalities have tied down Pakistan to IPPs.
Circular debt is Pakistan’s biggest and most immediate budgetary problem. As is evident from its nomenclature, circular debt has been created by dues and receivables that several oil, gas and power related companies owe to each other. Like the proverbial vicious circle of poverty, the “circular debt” is breeding and feeding itself. In this vicious circle, oil  and gas companies (Pakistan State Oil, Sui Northern Gas Pipeline, Sui Southern Gas Company),  refineries (Attock Oil Company, National Refinery and Pakistan Refinery) PEPCO and WAPDA,  their subsidiary distribution companies as well as major IPPs like HUBCO and KAPCO owe hundreds of billions of rupees to each other.
The government had inherited a huge backlog of circular debt when it came into power in late 2008, because Shaukat Aziz and company deliberately delayed adjustments resulting from rising oil prices.  The government parked a circular debt of Rs 300 billion in a holding company, and has been unable to meet even its interest obligations of Rs 40 billion per annum. Thus, Rs 40 billion is being added to the circular debt merely on account of interest charges.  The cumulative circular debt has risen to Rs 584 billion and was expected to touch Rs 781 billion by the end of the current fiscal year.
A story by The News reporter Mansoor Ahmad, in November revealed that “the finance ministry, in its presentation to the World Bank at the start of this fiscal year, conceded that another Rs 225 billion were added to the circular debt by end June (2010). It was also projected that by the end of the current fiscal year, a further Rs 256 billion would be added to the circular debt at an average of Rs 21.33 billion per month.”
Since the incumbent government assumed power, the electricity tariff has risen by 120 percent, but the price differential between the power purchase and the selling price has persisted. It has announced a further 2% increase for the next 12 months.  Will the price increase bridge the price differentials between the prices at which WAPDA/NTDC is buying power from the IPPs and selling to the consumer?  Even a layman can answer the question with an emphatic “no.” A study of the Turkish Rental Power Plant would suffice to highlight how IPPs or RPPs would keep piling up circular debt. NTDC/WAPDA would buy power from Karkey Kasradeniz Elekrik at 18 cents per unit or Rs 15.70 per unit and sell it to KESC at Rs 9.30 per unit. This means that NTDC/WAPDA would bear a subsidy of Rs 6.40 per unit from this RPP alone. Imagine the contribution it would make to the circular debt.
Given that PPIB has issued letters of intent and support to 54 additional IPPs and RPPs for 12,430 MW of new power, there is no way the government could do away with the circular debt resulting from power purchase and selling prices. Those well-versed with Pakistan’s economic history of the last 20 years – particularly the four packages negotiated with the IMF – are aware that Pakistan is trying to bring down the budget deficit to 4.5% of the GDP for 20 years. It was the target envisaged by the first package negotiated in 1988 and remains the elusive goal of the fourth package. Things remaining the same, it would be the goal of the fifth, sixth and seventh packages as well.

Poverty worsens as the economy deteriorates: Children scramble to find food. Photo: AFP

Del364123
Is there light at the end of the tunnel? Is there an alternative or are we faced with a TINA factor? There are alternatives but we cannot practice them because we have betrothed ourselves to World Bank-IMF dictated reforms catering to the interests of big businesses and multinationals. In times of depression and growing unemployment when the private sector is shy, it is the government which comes to the aid of the people by increasing government development plans. This happened under Z.A. Bhutto. In the 1970s, Bhutto financed several public sector projects like steel mills and fertiliser factories by printing notes. We cannot print notes because IMF has tied us down to a 4.5% budget deficit to the GDP. We cannot set up thermal power plants in the public sector and are thus forced to sign IPPs generating power at exorbitantly high prices. We are forced to introduce GST and RGST that discriminate against the domestic industry because under the same terms and conditions of the international lenders, we are required to reduce custom duties that make the goods of western countries cheaper in Pakistan. So unless and until Pakistan can rid itself of the economic agenda set by the donors and international financial institutions, it has little hope of coming out of the economic quagmire.

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

Pakistan’s Recipe to Disaster

Pakistan’s Recipe to Disaster

As per the latest Moody’s international report, Pakistani Rupee would continue to depreciate versus US dollars; the latest report said that Pakistani Rupee would further depreciate by 15% in 2012 to Rupees 99 a US dollar.

The report set alarming bells across all sections in Pakistan where the people and businesses are hoping for some good times by 2012. Report has also shaken Foreign and Local investor’s confidence from Pakistani Capital Markets and those who were planning to invest in Pakistan for longer-term period.

This report provides good chance for Pakistani people to invest their rupees in places where there are high returns. One of the best avenues is of course the money market, the other one is Gold where they can get higher returns.

But the situation in regional countries really astonishes me; countries like India, Bangladesh and Afghanistan have higher currency rate than Pakistani rupee. No one can forget that just few years’ earlier Indian rupee and Bangladesh Tika were extremely lowered than Pakistani rupee, and one Pakistani rupee was equal to 10,000 Afghania.

And still Afghanistan is heavily dependent on Pakistan for its food supplies and most of Pakistan’s wheat is smuggled into Afghanistan that causes Inflation inside Pakistan.

Pakistan by pursuing weaker currency policy is on its verge to disaster. Government of Pakistan should take hostile steps to defend its currency and save the economy as open market operations would kill the economy on just negative perceptions

As Pakistan nears bankruptcy, patience of foreign lenders wears thin

As Pakistan nears bankruptcy, patience of foreign lenders wears thin

A terrifying kind of mathematics has become popular among aid workers, analysts and others who spend their lives tracking the fate of Pakistan. It’s a back-of-the-envelope calculation about how the country will get through the coming years without declaring bankruptcy: take the country’s foreign debt ($53-billion), add interest, subtract the $1.8-billion that won’t arrive as scheduled on Jan. 1 from the International Monetary Fund because Islamabad failed to meet loan conditions. Add the staggering cost, perhaps $10-billion, of rebuilding after summer floods.

The numbers seem bleak. The government floated the possibility last week of running a deficit for the coming year of $15-billion.
Islamabad’s latest plan to raise revenue, a reformed tax law, has become bogged down by stubborn opposition parties, front-page criticism and street protests. The cabinet’s economic team is threatening to quit.

Pakistan needs a bailout. But is the country still a good investment?
“That’s the conversation people are having now, about whether you’d be throwing good money after bad,” said Mosharraf Zaidi, a development expert and policy analyst based in Islamabad.

The international community has accused Pakistan of poor financial management for years. Cables recently posted by the website WikiLeaks show a U.S. intelligence official complaining in 2008 about the country’s preference for spending money on strategic military hardware instead of development: “Despite pending economic catastrophe, Pakistan is producing nuclear weapons at a faster rate than any other country in the world.”

Patience with such behaviour wore especially thin as the government failed to honour several promises for cleaning up its balance sheet in recent months. As part of its IMF loan deals, Islamabad had vowed to cut electricity subsidies and find new ways of bringing in revenue. In particular, foreign donors wanted the country to crack down on its upper classes, notorious for shirking taxes.

Instead, the government responded by calling for debt forgiveness – not an absurd idea, in a country that spends up to 40 per cent of its annual budget servicing its debts, but still galling for international lenders.
The government also continued printing money to cover its costs.
Islamabad had promised to stop borrowing from its own state bank, but instead took almost $4-billion to prop up the budget – contributing to crippling inflation.

Defence spending increased this year, and will likely continue rising, while the government cut its development budget in half.
“If something like this happened in Canada, there would be a revolution,” Mr. Zaidi said recently at a fashionable coffee shop in Islamabad. Outside the window, however, in the leafy neighbourhood where expats shopped for Christmas decorations and luxury vehicles cruised slowly along well-paved streets, there was no sign of a revolt. That has been an enduring feature of Pakistani politics, the willingness of the middle and lower classes to absorb hardships. It remains an open question how long that trend will continue. Recent protests against the new Reformed General Sales Tax (RGST) were not widespread, but economists say the gross domestic product must grow an average of 7 per cent per year to keep up with the explosive number of young Pakistanis joining the work force.

The economy achieved that average rate of growth from 2000 to 2007, a period of declining poverty and unemployment, when Pakistan was mentioned among the so-called “Next Eleven” emerging economies by the U.S. investment bank Goldman Sachs.

But the growth streak slowed down as militancy erupted, particularly after the bloody storming of Islamabad’s Red Mosque in 2007. The government had hoped for 4.5 per cent growth in this fiscal year, but revised that down to 2.8 per cent after the recent floods.
Many of the nightmare scenarios envisioned after the floods have not emerged, however. Epidemics did not ravage the country as some predicted. The biggest export industry, cotton textiles, limped through the disaster but survived.

Pakistan’s own expatriate community abroad, which already sends home almost $10-billion per year, proved generous with their countrymen. In some backwater corners of the country, flood victims forced to live in camps have experienced better hygiene, education and health care than in their own villages. Those people could get a fresh start, if the international community decides to invest in major reconstruction.
“Let’s build better, this time,” Mengesha Kebede, the Pakistan head of the UN High Commission for Refugees. “There could be a qualitative improvement in the quality of life.”
Others say that demographic forces, and a thirst for education, will ensure that the country eventually pulls itself out of its current problems.

Tahir Andrabi, an economist at Pomona College who has been working on a four-year study of education in rural parts of central Pakistan, said the country already has the falling fertility rates and a growing cohort of educated women usually associated with strong development.“It’s remarkable, what’s happening in Pakistan,” Mr. Andrabi said.“This is supposed to be the most dangerous country in the world, and female education is skyrocketing.”
BLOG DIRECTORY, Submit blog free, Promote Blog, Best directory